• Home
  • About
  • Articles
  • Interviews
  • Models
  • Slides
  • Blog
Unconventional Wisdom
  • Home
  • About
  • Articles
  • Interviews
  • Models
  • Slides
  • Blog

Why ARE Financial Advisors’ Fees All Over the Map?

6/3/2013

0 Comments

 
This is definitely inside baseball talk so, if you're not in the financial services industry, it probably won't make sense to you. That said, you should probably understand what it means if you work with a financial advisor. This is my response to an article that appeared in Financial Advisor IQ entitled, Why Advisors’ Fees Are All Over the Map...

MY RESPONSE TO THE ARTICLE

In most cases, especially in the investment business, pricing anomalies like this are squeezed out of the system pretty quickly. Not sure if this article really answers the WHY question posed in the headline although Bob touches on it at the end. Lack of information on the part of advisors and clients partially explains it. But, after 30 years of working under the hood of advisor practices, I would offer some additional reasons to consider...
  1. The set of deliverables offered by advisors varies tremendously. This applies to RIAs as well as registered reps. Even within the large brokerage firms, where reps work for a national brand, the mix of product and services sold by advisors is so different that, if it were not for the company logos on the client statements, it would be difficult to know that the advisors worked for the same company.
  2. The only thing that differs more than the product and service mix is the knowledge and experience of the advisors. In other words, the quality of the "advice" itself varies greatly. Knowledge and experience (or lack thereof) is closely related to advisor confidence in their own professional worth. This certainly affects pricing decisions (such as whether to charge for planning or not) which are usually made or adjusted at the advisor level.
  3. A wise man once told me that investments are sold and not bought. If you buy that, you might be led to another plausible explanation which is that, at the end of the day, financial advisors are sales people. Advisors are paid a commission or a fee to SELL investment products and services, period. That's not a good thing or a bad thing. It just is what it is. As Dan Ariely says so eloquently, "Your motivation can't help but influence your behavior."
  4. The most plausible explanation of all (to me) is that most advisors today employ a pricing model that is not available to any other professional services group on the planet -- recurring asset based fees. If advisors charged by the hour, like most other professional service providers, this would be a moot discussion. By its very nature, the fee-based pricing model introduces huge inefficiencies into the system. For years, I have been preaching about the virtues of building a practice based on larger but fewer clients. The leverage that can be gained by doing this is impressive*. Consider the PROFITABILITY of managing as $5 million fee-based relationship versus a $500,000 one. While we may not want to talk about it publicly, this is the golden goose that allows this rare pricing inefficiency to exist. Why more advisors and firms don't capitalize on it is another story for another time.

* To appreciate this leverage please review the Lifetime Value of a Loyal Client chart below...
Picture
0 Comments

Don't Let Your Investor Experience Become a Horror Show...

7/26/2012

3 Comments

 

FINRA Fines Merrill Lynch $2.8 Million for Overcharging Customers;
$32 Million in Remediation Paid to Affected Customers...

Picture
WHY SHOULD YOU CARE?
Start by reading this news release from FINRA. Here is the punch line: "Investors must be able to trust that the fees charged by their securities firm are, in fact, correct. When this is not the case, investor confidence is threatened." That was the conclusion by Brad Bennett, FINRA's Chief of Enforcement. This article was inspired by that FINRA news release.

If you are an INVESTOR, you may be getting over-charged and/or misinformed. If you are an ADVISOR you could face similar outcomes (to the ones described in the FINRA news release) if you or your firm are over-charging or misinforming clients. Unfortunately, many investors do not know which questions to ask their financial advisors. Many advisors place blind faith in their firms and the investment managers they use. Both of these "don't know what you don't know" (or don't care to know) scenarios can lead to disastrous results.

WHAT CAN YOU DO?
Even if you were not affected by this particular incident or do business with another financial institution, you should START ASKING MORE QUESTIONS OF YOUR FINANCIAL ADVISOR. Advisors and the companies they work for use any number of software programs to handle the accounting, portfolio management and performance reporting functions of their businesses – ALL OF WHICH CAN AFFECT THE FEES YOU PAY. More importantly, advisors and the various products and services they use to manage your accounts MAKE MANY ASSUMPTIONS when it comes to the critical decisions that can directly affect your financial well-being.

Picture
For example, most advisors use some type of asset allocation software to determine how your portfolio should be structured (stocks vs bonds vs international, etc). All of those programs use algorithms (to determine the appropriate asset mix) that are based on assumptions that may or may not be valid or realistic. One of the most important is the RATE OF RETURN EXPECTATION, also known as "capital market assumptions," that these and other financial planning programs use to crunch numbers. Think about this for a minute. If an advisor says you need to put away X dollars per year or have Y dollars in your retirement account by the time you reach 65 to provide you with a certain monthly income, there are mathematical assumptions being made. YOU SHOULD KNOW WHAT THOSE ASSUMPTIONS ARE. 

Listed below are some questions you should ask. If you do understand this, find someone who does and take time to learn it. Unless you have given your financial advisor legal discretion to trade on your behalf (which is unlikely) YOU are making the ultimate decisions when it comes to your investments. Technically speaking, your advisor is just making recommendations. I know this gets a little confusing for some people but it is VERY important since it can have a significant impact on your family's financial well being. Do NOT be surprised if your advisor cannot answer some or all of these questions. If you find that to be the case, you should re-evaluate your relationship and start looking for alternatives when it comes to financial advice. You will find some helpful resources below.

Questions To Ask Your Financial Advisor...

Picture
Help me understand how ALL fees are calculated on my accounts? Pay close attention to fee-based accounts which automatically debit your account based on portfolio values at specific points in time (e.g., quarter end)

What other fees am I paying that may not be “visible" in my accounts? Most investment products, especially mutual funds and annuities, have internal management fees (and other fees which are used to compensate financial advisors) that are NOT visible on your account statements. Find out how much you are paying and compare that to fees on competing products. [Be sure to get some objective input on that last point]

What assumptions are you making to formulate the advice you are giving me?  Specifically, what rate of return expectations are you using to determine my asset allocation?  What are those expectations based on?  What adjustments have you made to your assumptions in the past 12 months? When and why would you make changes to those assumptions?

What software programs are you using to analyze my portfolio and prepare my financial plan? What assumptions do those programs make (e.g., capital market assumptions)? When were those software programs last updated? What steps have you taken to ensure that you are using the best tools to formulate the advice you are giving me?

How do you select your (my) benchmarks? Benchmarks are "yardsticks" that let you know how your portfolio is doing. Examples include the S&P 500 and other indices that are used to measure the aggregate price levels of certain "baskets" of securities or entire asset classes. Your investment accounts are probably being compared to several benchmarks. Those benchmarks are usually selected by your advisor and/or the product and service providers he/she employs, such as mutual funds, money managers, etc.

PLEASE NOTE: Each asset class will have its own expected rate of return assumption. In the case of asset allocation software, the algorithms also make certain assumptions about the correlation of the various asset classes (i.e., to what degree their prices move together). All of these assumption, which are used to make critical investment and financial planning decisions ON YOUR BEHALF are usually based on historical data. This is what makes them so "iffy" and why it so important that you take the time to learn this stuff. 

The Importance of Using Realistic Capital Markets Assumptions... 

This video does an excellent job of explaining what rate of return expectations are and why they are important. It also explains how rate of return expectations are derived and how they can impact financial plans and investment portfolios.

While the concepts and process described in this interview pertain to one of the largest institutional funds in the world, they are virtually identical to the ones you and your advisor should be discussing.

Learn More
  • CalPERS Asset Allocation Process
  • Download a full transcript of this interview
In this interview, the chief investment officer and interim chief actuary for CalPERS discuss the process they use to review and adjust their pension fund's assumptions.

The Importance of Selecting the Right Benchmarks...

Please note that mutual funds and money managers usually select their own benchmarks. That is, they select which yardsticks they think their performance should be compared to.

A cynic might say this is like the fox guarding the proverbial chicken coop so make sure you understand what's going on here. The video to the left and the white papers below address this important and often overlooked aspect of investment management.

Do NOT be surprised if your financial advisor gets stumped here. If that happens you should view this as a mutual learning experience. 
If you do not understand the conversation in this video, you should find someone who can explain what it means and how it can impact your financial well-being. If your financial advisor cannot or will not interpret this for you, you should find one who can. That would be a very bad sign.

Explore More...

Picture
Here are some resources you might find helpful...

  • Playing To Win - Ron Surz
  • A Test of Faith - Ron Surz
  • Trust But Verify - Ron Surz
  • How To Avoid Problems with Your Broker - FINRA
  • How To Find A Financial Advisor - NAPFA
  • What You Need to Know Before Choosing A Financial Advisor - SEC
  • Understanding Professional Designations Used by Financial Professionals - FINRA
  • Merrill Lynch Gets Fined for Overcharging Customers - FINRA
  • Governance Gone Wrong, Very Very Wrong - related blog post
  • Investment Planning & Policy Development - related presentation
3 Comments

    RAMBLE ON

    Picture
    Picture
    Picture

    RAMBLE ON, the name of my SLOG was inspired by the Led Zeppelin song with the same name. It also describes the content, which reflects my very random observations about life, work and my endless pursuit of the sublime. See tag list below...

    Archives

    November 2013
    June 2013
    May 2013
    April 2013
    March 2013
    February 2013
    January 2013
    December 2012
    November 2012
    October 2012
    September 2012
    August 2012
    July 2012
    June 2012

    Tags

    All
    3rd Alternative
    Aaron Hernandez
    Abuelito
    Advisors Fees
    Andrew Zolli
    Angela Maiers
    Anniversary
    Aspen Institute
    Asset Based Fees
    Asset Class
    A To B Syndrome
    Attitude
    Authenticity
    Best Band Ever
    Blackberry
    Blown Away Guy
    Book Reviews
    Books
    Bookstore
    Brain
    Brene Brown
    Brother David Steindl-Rast
    Business Optimization
    Cavemen
    Charts
    Child Development
    Clay Christensen
    Client Advocacy
    Client Experience
    Cliff
    Clouds
    Coaching
    Coffee Is For Closers
    Communication
    Competition
    Consulting
    Content Marketing
    Copernicus Radio
    Coral Gables
    Crying Cow
    Culture Narrative
    Curiosity
    Dan Ariely
    Dan Fogelberg
    Dishonesty
    Education
    Einstein
    Election
    Environment
    Epicurean Friends
    Exit
    Experience
    Extrapolation Bias
    Farm Bill
    Fast Cars
    Fee-based
    Financial Advisor Iq
    Financial Advisors
    Finra
    Fiscal Cliff
    Foresight
    Fusion Impact
    Gambler
    Glengarry Glen Ross
    Google
    Governance
    Gratitude
    Health
    Humor
    Indifference
    Infrastructure
    Innovation
    Inspired Thinking
    Investment Policy
    I Wonder
    Janisse Ray
    Jim Brown
    John Gardner
    Joni Mitchell
    Krista Tippett
    Leadership
    Led Zeppelin
    Let It Shine
    Listening
    Loyalty
    Marketing
    Market Timing
    Mark Kelly
    Maxell
    Merrill Lynch
    Miami
    Michelangelo
    Monkberry Moon Delight
    Nasa
    National Nutrition Month
    New York
    Nobel Prize
    Nutrition
    Obama
    On Being
    Philosophy
    Pieta
    Politicians
    Practice Management
    Pricing Anomolies
    Productivity
    Ram
    Ramble On
    Reich
    Resilience Thinking
    Rim
    Romney
    Schwartzberg
    Sculptors
    Self-renewal
    Slog
    Social Media
    Space
    Sports
    Stephen Covey
    Storytelling
    Strategy
    Sustainability
    Talking White Paper
    Teachers
    Team Building
    Technology
    Ted
    Templeton
    Think Outside Box
    Time In Vs Timing
    Travel
    Truth
    Unconventional Wisdom
    Video
    Voice
    Vulnerability
    Wealth Management
    What Is A Slog?
    Win-win
    You Matter


    My "Fiscal Cliff" Playlist

    Sonos Wireless Music Player

    1 FREE Audiobook RISK-FREE from Audible


    Picture
    "When you realize how little you know, you have become a philosopher."
    ~ Socrates ~


    Picture
    Picture
    Picture
    Picture
Picture
Articles & Papers | Talking White Papers | Conceptual Models | Radio Interviews | Slides & Training
  • Home
  • About
  • Articles
  • Interviews
  • Models
  • Slides
  • Blog